Dennis Villeneuve’s new film dune Adapted from Frank Herbert’s 1965 novel.TV writer Andrea Kyle It is said that the new film is much more successful than the early adaptation of the story.
“It lived up to my every expectation,” Kyle said in episode 491 Geek Galaxy Guide podcast. “This is exactly one of my favorite books of all time that I wish to adapt.”
Geek Galaxy Guide host David Barr Courtley agree dune It is a first-class adaptation. “It’s great to have science fiction films made by people who really respect the source material,” he said. “In contrast to the 80s, they often held a book, and the director would just say,’I have a lot of better ideas than this stupid book,’ and they would change everything.”
Fantasy writer Raj Cana I like this movie, but hope it contains more novel and rich world architecture. “A lot of weird things have been skipped-a lot of spiritual things, Dr. Yueh and his entire conditioning, and more in-depth Bene Gesserit and Kwisatz Haderach, and the guild navigator,” he said. “In this movie I was disappointed by the least exposed things in the novel because I think one of the advantages of this novel is that he came up with strange things.”
Science fiction writer Matthew Krassel Hope there is an extended version dune He might recover some of his favorite scenes from the book.He is also happy to see more dune The universe is in the upcoming sequel Sand Dunes: Part Two. “This is dune The movie I always wanted,” he said. “I’m excited about the sequel. The waiting time is long, but we have waited long enough for this, so I can wait another year or two. “
Listen to the full interview with Andrea Kail, Rajan Khanna and Matthew Kressel in episode 491 Geek Galaxy Guide (above). And check out some of the highlights in the discussion below.
Rajan Khanna on the adaptation:
“I’m not the target audience for this movie. Although I love dune As a novel, film adaptation is almost unnecessary for me. I have a book that I can read, and that book has some things. For me, film adaptations are always the exercises of “Oh, they changed that” and “Oh, how do they deal with this problem is fun”.Sometimes it can be amazing, but I’m not one of those people who say, “I really want them to remake dune As a movie, make it very good. So this meets my expectations.If this is a bad movie, I will be disappointed, but I will not feel betrayed in any way, or it will ruin my chances of getting a good movie dune adapt. “
Matthew Kressel on pacing:
“There is a part in the movie, maybe two-thirds to three-quarters, I think we are just playing’chasing the mouse’. It’s basically like, chase scene, pause, battle scene, chase scene, pause, The battle scene. One thing, when they went to the research station, Dr. Keynes Show them the plants and explain that she wants to make a green Arrakis. I thought, “This is cool”, and then another fighting scene appeared immediately. …All these scenes are great, but for a while I invested a little less in it because it lasted a long time. I think, in those moments, I want more stories. “
Andrea Kail about features:
“This is a story of growth. [Paul] Becoming a man-not only to assume the role of the father of the duke, but also to get rid of the control of the mother. Because she said, “We have to leave this world,” he interrupted her and said, “No. Our path is through the desert,” she just needs to accept it. There is a scene, just before the end, he and Chani watch He looked at each other, and then he looked at his mother. She knew he had been having these dreams, and she found that this was the girl he dreamed of. They smiled at each other, and then Paul walked away and you would see Jessica’s face This subtle change in the above, from “happy” to “indifferent”. This means that she does not want him to be with her.”
David Barr Courtley in Hollywood:
“I have always just assumed that every two or three months there will be a big science fiction movie that we can talk about, but because of the pandemic, it hasn’t been in the past two years. I never really realized how much this would bring me. Loss, to be honest, how difficult it is to do sci-fi podcasts once a week…so I appreciate how unstable Hollywood is actually. It looks powerful, but if people don’t watch these movies, If you don’t go to the cinema, it may disappear. So I have a new appreciation for directors like Dennis Villeneuve and movies like this. I just hope that everyone will do their best to support them. If you want to If things continue to exist.”